This document explores questioning as a core counselling skill, covering open-ended and closed-ended questions, specialized question types including leading questions and rhetorical questions, funnelling techniques, and understanding client response patterns in therapeutic contexts.
This document examines questioning as an essential counselling skill that becomes increasingly important as the therapeutic process progresses. It distinguishes between open-ended and closed-ended questions, exploring their distinct purposes, appropriate applications, and impact on client communication and exploration.
As counsellors move through the counselling process, questioning skills become increasingly important. The ability to ask the right type of question at the right time can significantly influence the depth and direction of therapeutic conversation, helping clients explore their thoughts and feelings while providing counsellors with necessary information.
Questions in counselling serve multiple purposes beyond simply gathering information. They can motivate communication, encourage elaboration, elicit specific examples, and help define the boundaries of issues being explored. The effectiveness of questioning depends largely on understanding when and how to use different question types.
Counselling questions fall into two fundamental categories, each serving distinct purposes and eliciting different types of responses from clients. Understanding the characteristics and appropriate applications of each type enables counsellors to guide therapeutic conversations effectively.
Open-ended questions are those that cannot be easily answered with yes, no, or a very short phrase. They are not normally used to gain specific information but rather to explore feelings and thoughts in depth.
Open-ended questions are used to accomplish several therapeutic objectives:
| Purpose | Description |
|---|---|
| Begin an interview | Create an open, exploratory atmosphere at the start of sessions |
| Encourage elaboration | Invite clients to expand on their thoughts and feelings |
| Elicit specific examples | Help clients provide concrete instances of experiences |
| Motivate communication | Encourage clients to engage more fully in the therapeutic process |
Open-ended questions typically begin with words like “how,” “what,” or “why,” and invite extended responses. They create space for clients to explore their internal experiences and provide details according to their own priorities.
Examples of effective open-ended questions include:
These questions invite clients to reflect deeply and share their personal perspectives rather than simply confirming or denying specific facts.
Closed-ended questions are those that can be answered with a yes, no, or a very short phrase. They serve specific purposes in gathering concrete information and defining the parameters of issues.
Closed-ended questions are used to accomplish different therapeutic objectives:
| Purpose | Description |
|---|---|
| Obtain specific information | Gather concrete facts or confirm particular details |
| Identify parameters | Establish the scope and boundaries of an issue |
| Break into a narrative | Interrupt when clients become stuck in repetitive storytelling |
| Define boundaries | Clarify the limits and extent of particular situations |
Closed-ended questions typically elicit brief, factual responses. They help counsellors gather specific information efficiently and can provide structure when conversations become too diffuse.
Examples of effective closed-ended questions include:
These questions allow counsellors to quickly assess particular aspects of the client’s experience or situation, often serving to clarify or confirm specific points.
Knowing when to use open or closed questions represents a key skill in counselling. The choice between question types depends on the therapeutic purpose at that moment in the session and the kind of information or exploration needed.
Open-ended questions work best when:
Closed-ended questions work best when:
Important
While both question types have their place in counselling, overuse of closed-ended questions can make sessions feel like interrogations rather than therapeutic conversations. Conversely, using only open-ended questions may make it difficult to gather necessary specific information. Effective counsellors develop skill in balancing both types according to therapeutic needs.
Beyond the basic distinction between open and closed questions, counsellors should be aware of several specialized question types that can either enhance or hinder therapeutic effectiveness.
Leading questions subtly point the respondent’s answer in a particular direction, often implying a certain perspective or judgment.
A leading question usually contains an implicit assumption or judgment that may influence how clients respond. For example, asking “How are you getting on with the new finance system?” subtly implies that there might be difficulties with the system, potentially prompting the client to focus on problems rather than providing a balanced assessment.
A less leading alternative would be “Tell me about your experience with the new finance system,” which does not require any judgment and does not imply that something may be wrong.
Children and vulnerable individuals are particularly susceptible to leading questions and more likely to take cues from the counsellor’s phrasing. A simple question like “Did you have a good day at school?” points the child toward thinking about positive experiences, while “How was school today?” allows for a more balanced, accurate response without implied judgment.
Caution
Leading questions should generally be avoided in counselling practice as they can inadvertently direct clients toward particular answers rather than allowing authentic exploration of their experiences. The way questions are framed can significantly shape the direction of subsequent conversation and the information gathered.
Questions can be categorized by the cognitive demands they place on clients, distinguishing between those requiring recall of information and those requiring deeper analysis.
Recall questions require clients to remember or retrieve specific information from memory. These are essentially factual questions that have definite answers.
Examples include:
These questions help establish facts and timelines but do not necessarily promote deeper exploration or insight.
Process questions require more thought, analysis, reflection, or sharing of opinion. They invite clients to engage in deeper cognitive and emotional processing.
Examples include:
Process questions are particularly valuable in counselling as they encourage insight development and deeper self-understanding.
| Question Type | Cognitive Demand | Therapeutic Value | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recall | Lower - retrieval of facts | Establishing information | “When did this begin?” |
| Process | Higher - analysis and reflection | Promoting insight | “What does this pattern mean to you?” |
Rhetorical questions are designed to promote thought rather than elicit direct answers. They do not require or expect a response but serve to engage clients’ thinking about particular issues.
Rhetorical questions can be powerful tools for promoting reflection. Examples include questions like “Who would not want to achieve their goals?” or “If you had succeeded by trying to fail, would that be success or failure?”
While rhetorical questions are commonly used in public speaking to maintain audience engagement, their use in counselling should be limited and purposeful. They can help clients consider perspectives they might not have contemplated, but overuse may feel manipulative or philosophical rather than therapeutic.
Note
Rhetorical questions should be used sparingly in counselling. While they can occasionally prompt useful reflection, direct questions that invite genuine response are generally more appropriate for therapeutic work.
Funnelling involves using a series of questions that become progressively more or less restrictive at each step, creating a structured path through a topic.
This approach starts with open questions and progressively narrows to more closed, specific questions:
This technique allows counsellors to begin with exploration and gradually focus on specific details. It can be particularly useful when trying to gather comprehensive information about a topic while maintaining a conversational flow.
Conversely, questioning can start with closed questions and work toward more open questions:
This reverse funnelling can be useful when meeting someone new or when clients are hesitant to share. Starting with simpler, more concrete questions can help build comfort before moving to more exploratory territory.
| Funnelling Direction | Best Used When | Therapeutic Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Broad to Narrow | Gathering comprehensive information | Start with exploration, focus on specifics |
| Narrow to Broad | Building rapport with new or hesitant clients | Start with comfortable questions, expand gradually |
Important
Funnelling techniques should be used flexibly and responsively. The counsellor should remain attuned to client responses and adjust the questioning path based on what emerges rather than rigidly following a predetermined sequence.
Counsellors must recognize that clients may respond to questions in various ways, not all of which involve direct, honest answers. Understanding potential response patterns helps counsellors navigate conversations more effectively.
Clients may respond to questions in several different ways:
| Response Type | Description | Counsellor Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Direct and Honest | Straightforward, genuine answer | The ideal response that provides accurate information |
| Lying | Deliberately false information | May be detected through inconsistencies or non-verbal cues |
| Out of Context | Unconnected or irrelevant response | May indicate confusion; consider rewording the question |
| Partial Answer | Selective answering of parts of questions | Clients may avoid difficult aspects; gentle follow-up may be needed |
| Avoidance | Deflecting or changing the topic | Often indicates discomfort with the question or topic |
| Stalling | Answering questions with questions | May signal need for time to formulate an acceptable answer |
| Distortion | Answers influenced by bias or social desirability | May not be intentional; clients may exaggerate to appear more normal |
| Refusal | Explicit or implicit refusal to answer | Should be respected; explore the reluctance if appropriate |
When clients do not provide direct answers, counsellors should:
Note
Not all evasive responses indicate resistance or dishonesty. Clients may struggle to articulate experiences, may not yet trust the therapeutic relationship sufficiently to share openly, or may genuinely not know how to answer. Patience and skillful follow-up questioning often help clients move toward more complete responses when they are ready.
Knowing when to use open or closed questions is a key skill in counselling. Consider the following scenarios and determine whether open or closed questions are best to use in each one, then formulate an appropriate question.
Situation: The counsellor wants to know how the client has been feeling since their last session.
Question Type: Open-ended
Rationale: This situation calls for exploration of the client’s emotional experience over time, inviting them to share their feelings in their own words rather than confirming a specific feeling.
Example Question: “How have you been feeling since we last met?”
Situation: The counsellor wants to know if clients feel they are progressing in resolving the issues they presented with.
Question Type: This could use either type depending on the depth of exploration desired:
Example Questions:
Rationale: A closed question provides a quick assessment, while an open question invites the client to describe their experience of progress in more detail. The choice depends on the therapeutic moment and what level of exploration is appropriate.
Situation: The counsellor wants to know what clients think could help them.
Question Type: Open-ended
Rationale: This situation seeks to explore the client’s own ideas and perspectives about what might be helpful, inviting them to share their thoughts rather than confirming a specific option.
Example Question: “What do you think might help you with this situation?”
Note
These scenarios demonstrate that question choice depends on the therapeutic purpose. While guidelines exist, effective counsellors develop intuition about when each type serves the client’s needs best. Practice and reflection help build this crucial skill.
Questioning represents a fundamental counselling skill that becomes increasingly important as the therapeutic process progresses. While the basic distinction between open-ended and closed-ended questions provides the foundation for effective questioning, counsellors must also understand specialized question types and their implications. Leading questions should generally be avoided as they can inadvertently direct client responses, while recall and process questions serve different cognitive and therapeutic purposes. Rhetorical questions have limited but occasionally useful applications in promoting reflection.
The funnelling technique offers a structured approach to questioning, whether moving from broad exploration to specific details or building comfort through narrow-to-broad progression. Understanding the various ways clients may respond to questions—from direct honesty to avoidance or distortion—enables counsellors to navigate conversations with greater skill and sensitivity.
Effective counsellors develop the ability to select appropriate question types based on therapeutic purpose, remain flexible in their questioning approach, and respond skillfully to the diverse ways clients may answer. This mastery enhances the counsellor’s capacity to facilitate meaningful therapeutic conversation, gather necessary information, and support clients in exploring their concerns with appropriate depth while respecting their boundaries and readiness to engage with difficult material.
Open-ended questions are primarily used to explore feelings and thoughts in depth rather than to gain specific information. They are used to:
(2) “How did you feel when that happened?” is an open-ended question because it cannot be answered with a simple yes or no and invites the client to explore and describe their emotional experience in their own words.
Closed-ended questions work best when:
| Purpose | Question Type |
|---|---|
| A. Encourage elaboration on thoughts and feelings | 1. Closed-ended |
| B. Obtain specific information | 2. Open-ended |
| C. Elicit specific examples | 3. Closed-ended |
| D. Identify parameters of an issue | 4. Open-ended |
A-4 (Open-ended), B-1 (Closed-ended), C-4 (Open-ended), D-3 (Closed-ended).
(2) Encouraging clients to elaborate on feelings is a purpose of open-ended questions, not closed-ended questions. Closed-ended questions are used to obtain specific information, break into narratives, and define boundaries.
Open-ended questions are normally used to gain specific information about facts and details.
False. Open-ended questions are not normally used to gain specific information but rather to explore feelings and thoughts in depth. Closed-ended questions are used to obtain specific information.
(3) Exploring how a client has been feeling since the last session calls for an open-ended question because it invites the client to share their emotional experience in their own words rather than confirming a specific feeling or providing a factual answer.
| Question | Type |
|---|---|
| A. “How is that important to you?” | 1. Closed-ended |
| B. “Are you angry?” | 2. Open-ended |
| C. “What are your reasons for saying that?” | 3. Closed-ended |
| D. “How many times have you done that?” | 4. Open-ended |
A-4 (Open-ended), B-1 (Closed-ended), C-4 (Open-ended), D-3 (Closed-ended).
Effective counsellors should use only open-ended questions to avoid making sessions feel like interrogations.
False. While overuse of closed-ended questions can make sessions feel like interrogations, using only open-ended questions may make it difficult to gather necessary specific information. Effective counsellors develop skill in balancing both types according to therapeutic needs.
(3) The document states that “as counsellors move through the counselling process, questioning skills become increasingly important.” This indicates that questioning becomes more significant as therapy progresses, not less.
SkillsYouNeed. Question Types. https://www.skillsyouneed.com/ips/question-types.html